This is the film nobody thought would ever come out. It's had more release dates than I've had roast dinners and multiple production issues so I honestly didn't think it would ever come out. And after seeing it, I kind of feel that would be best for the film.
Let's start with the positives however, the best thing about this film is Anya Taylor-Joy. She has the strongest screen presence, the most interesting character and is the strongest actor in this film. She has some really great moments throughout the film and I really look forward to seeing her in the future. The rest of the cast are really good but Anya is by far the best.
Also the CGI are very good and very effective in some scenes. Now I will be calling this back in the negative but from what we get of the visuals, it's really good.
There's also some really nice call backs to the x men continuity and I really appreciated that so this doesn't feel insignificant to the rest of the films.
Unfortunately we need to get into the negatives and this film is a complete mess. I am struggling to believe there was no studio interference because when you get to the 3rd act, it feels like a different film.
This film just cannot decide what it wants to be. It jumps from being a character study, to a horror film, to a generic superhero film. And even when it works well as a character study, it's incredibly reminiscent to Glass. Yes this film was already made before Glass but play these two films together, they are very similar films.
On another level, the film logically makes no sense. This one woman played by Alice Braga is in charge of a big facility, in charge of these powerful mutants and not one of them tries to overpower her and escape. It's just her and although she has powers, she is not as powerful as any other of the mutants. I noticed it pretty much as soon as the facility was established into the film and as it went along, my point just kept getting proven more and more.
Speaking of Alice Braga, she is seriously miscast in this film. She gives a good performance but I really don't think she fits the role at all. There's one scene where there's an incident, she's running towards the incident but the way she runs is so comedic, it feels like an unintentional comedy. I also think Maisie Williams was miscast as well. She loses her Scottish accent in places and when she transitions into her abilities, she feels like a screaming child; once again, making this film into an unintentional comedy.
This film also has some serious pacing issues. Once we get to the facility, there's so much dialogue and exposition, the main plotline doesn't start until it feels around halfway through the film. Speaking of the dialogue, it is either very predictable or weirdly cringeworthy.
Once we get to the 3rd act, this is when it feels like a very different film because it goes from being very confined to portal jumping and very CGI heavy. This is when I wonder if this whole sequence was a studio produced reshoot because I did read there was studio interference although I could have read wrong. There's also not a lot of chemistry between any of the new mutants, there isn't any team dynamics between them.
Finally and whilst this is a nitpick, it did bug me that they were watching Buffy the vampire slayer and it spoiled it for me a little. I'm halfway through season 2 and I didn't appreciate the spoilers in the upcoming seasons.
Overall, whilst I do appreciate Fox trying something different, this is a really dull, messy film that just failed to live up to the hype and it's really disappointing to me.
⭐⭐